Late-autumn lawn and mature tree beside a well-kept older gray clapboard house on a compact coastal New Jersey lot.

What You're Paying for When You Buy an Older Home in Avon-by-the-Sea

At 101 Fourth Avenue in Avon-by-the-Sea, the tax record assesses the house at $102,700. It assesses the ground under it at $1,335,000. The house is a one-story home built in 1929, about 1,200 square feet, with a basement and a detached garage. On paper, the building accounts for about 7% of the property's assessed value.

That address is an extreme case, but it points the same way as the other older homes that came before Avon's Planning Board in 2026. When you buy an older house in Avon, most of the price is for the lot. So what you are really buying is the chance to decide what stands on that lot next. The board's 2026 docket shows the terms that come with that chance. Hearings take months, plans are often cut down for height or coverage, and sometimes keeping the old house turns out to be the better move.

A borough with no spare ground

Avon's 2025 Housing Element describes the borough as a historic seaside community with "little vacant or unused space," with homes on most of its land. The same plan reports that a bit more than half of the borough's occupied homes were built before 1950, and the median year of construction is 1948.

When a town can't add land, the land carries the value and the houses wear out on top of it. The borough's assessments show this. Here is how the tax rolls, as listed on NJParcels, split several of this year's board addresses between land and building:

Address Land assessment Improvement assessment House share of total
101 Fourth Avenue $1,335,000 $102,700 about 7%
211 Marine Place $419,000 $252,600 about 38%
25 Woodland Avenue $1,200,000 $800,000 40%
39 East End Avenue $600,000 $441,300 about 42%
500 Norwood Avenue $492,200 $365,000 about 43%
112 Garfield Avenue $925,000 $885,100 about 49%

Assessments are not sale prices. They are still the borough's own record of where the value sits, and in every row the land is worth more than the building. You can see the sources for each figure on the records for 101 Fourth Avenue, 112 Garfield Avenue, 39 East End Avenue, 25 Woodland Avenue, 211 Marine Place and 500 Norwood Avenue.

Keep this in mind when you compare Avon with nearby towns on price per square foot, as we did in our comparison of Manasquan and Avon. For an older Avon house, much of the number being divided is the ground, spread across whatever house happens to be standing on it.

What the docket shows about rebuilding

What can go on an Avon lot is settled in the Planning Board's minutes, one address at a time. The board meets in the Avon Marina Building at 2 Main Street, a room we wrote about in our post on Avon's off-season civic calendar.

112 Garfield Avenue was heard on February 26. The plan was to demolish and rebuild the front house on a full-sized lot and renovate the rear house, which has a garage apartment. The architect said the height variance was needed because of flood regulations, and the applicants told the board they hoped to be approved before NJDEP's REAL rules took effect. Three neighbors spoke in favor. Board members raised no concerns about the height but pressed for less lot coverage, and the applicants asked to carry the hearing to March 23. The application was approved at the March meeting, after revised plans that reduced the size of the house. The record lists the last sale of the property at $1,245,000 in May 2014.

539 Lakeside Avenue was a plan to demolish the existing house and build a new single-family home. The board approved it with conditions, one of which was a one-foot cut in height. The resolution was approved on May 26.

101 Fourth Avenue, the 7% house from the opening, was heard on July 27. The architect testified that the existing structure could not support a second story. He proposed a 2,800-square-foot shingle-style home with no basement and no third floor, so the mechanicals would sit inside the living space, and he described the design as sensitive to both the Fourth Avenue streetscape and the Shark River view. The application was carried to the October 26 meeting. The November 23 agenda lists Resolution 27-2026 for it.

39 East End Avenue, an early-1900s house, was proposed as a single-family rebuild with coverage variances. Its hearing was carried from August to October as well. It is on the same November 23 agenda under Resolution 26-2026. The record shows its last sale at $712,000 in October 2012.

Put on a calendar, a rebuild application in Avon this year has taken anywhere from one meeting cycle to more than four months. Many plans came out shorter or smaller than they went in.

When the use of the property changes

Two of the year's approvals changed what a property is, as well as what it looks like.

At 25 Woodland Avenue, the owners proposed demolishing a guest cottage, ending the property's use as a rooming house, and building a five-bedroom single-family home. The board approved the plan in May and adopted the resolution in July.

At 211 Marine Place, a house more than 100 years old on a very undersized lot, then used as a rental, is to be replaced by a 2.5-story, three-bedroom primary residence. The plan includes two parking spaces on the lot, a bike shed and a small covered porch. The architect said she designed it to look as if it could have been built in the early 1900s. Neighbors who spoke were in favor, and the board approved it on September 28. Its last recorded sale was $66,000 in October 1997, and the land under it is now assessed at $419,000.

The house that was worth keeping

The application at 500 Norwood Avenue shows the other side. The house was built in 1939 and sold for $650,000 in May 2018. It sits on a 4,500-square-foot triangular lot with three street frontages. The architect testified that the one-story structure was in good condition and could take a second story, so the plan kept the house and added onto it, bringing it to about 2,600 square feet. Eight neighbors spoke in support, and the board approved it as submitted on September 28. Earlier that year, on August 24, the board approved an addition to an existing home at 432 Garfield Avenue.

Compare 500 Norwood with 101 Fourth. Both started as one-story homes from about the same era, and both owners wanted roughly the same amount of living space. The difference was whether the existing frame could carry another floor. That one structural fact decides whether the improvement value on the tax bill is worth something to the next owner or is just the cost of demolition.

The rare new lots

Avon gets very little new supply, which helps explain why land carries so much of the value. One 2026 approval adds some. At 125 Washington Avenue, the former US Coast Guard station on the Shark River, the board approved a major subdivision into six home lots and one shared lot for a homeowners association. Each home gets its own boat slip, and all are reached by a private lane that extends Washington Lane. The approval came on May 12, and the resolution followed on June 22. The project adds six homes to the borough, all from a single former government site.

The county market around it

Avon's older homes sell inside a busy county market. New Jersey REALTORS® reports that Monmouth County single-family homes sold at a median of $844,450 in October 2026. Homes spent a median 35 days on market until sale, sellers received 100.7% of list price, and inventory stood at 3.0 months of supply. These are county figures, not Avon's. They do show a market where buyers paid list price this fall. In Avon, much of that price is for the ground, and an older house whose land is assessed at about thirteen times the building is priced on what can be built there.

The docket is still active. The November 23 agenda includes new applications for 501 Jefferson Avenue and for 107 Norwood Avenue, which is seeking a use variance.

Questions buyers ask

Is an older Avon home a teardown by default? No. At 500 Norwood Avenue, a sound 1939 structure was kept and expanded. At 101 Fourth Avenue, the architect testified the house could not carry a second story. Before you price a house as a lot, find out whether its structure can support more house.

How long has the board process taken this year? Based on the 2026 minutes, 112 Garfield Avenue went from first hearing to approval in about a month. Applications at 101 Fourth Avenue and 39 East End Avenue were carried over several months before resolutions reached the November agenda.

Do approved plans come out the same as proposed? Often they don't. This year the board approved a smaller house at 112 Garfield Avenue and a one-foot height reduction at 539 Lakeside Avenue.

If you're looking at an older house in Avon and wondering whether its value is in the building or the lot, Shire Realty can help. We'll go through the assessment record, the board's recent decisions on nearby streets and the comparable sales with you before you make an offer. Speak with a Jersey Shore real estate expert on our buyers page, or start with our Avon-by-the-Sea neighborhood guide.

Work With Us

Shire Realty combines traditional marketing and sales techniques with proven new technologies to help sell your home quickly and help you to get the best price. Contact Shire Realty today to get started in the buying or selling process!

Follow Shire Realty on Instagram